| Comune | Repubblica | Monarchia | Elettori | Votanti | Affluenza | Bianche | Nulle |
| Anghiari | 3.396 (77,75%) | 972 (22,25%) | 5.394 | 4.912 | 91,06% | 479 | 65 |
| Badia Tedalda | 1.404 (82,88%) | 290 (17,12%) | 2.141 | 1.856 | 86,69% | 142 | 20 |
| Caprese Michelangelo | 1.143 (69,23%) | 508 (30,77%) | 2.012 | 1.846 | 91,75% | 178 | 17 |
| Monterchi | 1.070 (60,01%) | 713 (39,99%) | 2.091 | 1.938 | 92,68% | 133 | 22 |
| Pieve Santo Stefano | 2.082 (75,27%) | 684 (24,73%) | 3.569 | 3.136 | 87,87% | 322 | 48 |
| Sansepolcro | 5.536 (79,34%) | 1.442 (20,66%) | 8.123 | 7.521 | 92,59% | 471 | 72 |
| Sestino | 1.044 (57,74%) | 764 (42,26%) | 2.175 | 1.942 | 89,29% | 105 | 29 |
| Totale Valtiberina | 15.675 (74,47%) | 5.373 (25,53%) | 25.505 | | | | |
